A circuit judge has denied pretrial immunity in a St. Augustine felony gun case, the St. Johns Citizen reported, and the order rests on the defendant’s own recording. Circuit Judge Christopher Ferebee ruled Nov. 13 that the defendant is not entitled to immunity under Florida’s Stand Your Ground law, according to the Citizen’s report of the order. The defendant is a private investigator based in Duval County, and she faces a charge of aggravated assault with a firearm in St. Johns County. The charge arises from a Jan. 24 confrontation on North Orange Street in St. Augustine.
A Stand Your Ground immunity hearing is a pretrial proceeding, and it is decided by a judge rather than by a jury. A defendant who wins one cannot be prosecuted on the charge at all, which is the reason the motion is heard first. The hearing on the motion ran two days, Oct. 7 and Oct. 14, per the Citizen’s report. Judge Ferebee found that prosecutors had established that the defendant’s threatened use of force in the January confrontation was unjustified.
The encounter began while the investigator was attempting to serve papers in an unrelated case, according to the Citizen’s account. She approached a home the man rented, and the renter testified that he saw her opening his mailbox and examining mail. She denied examining the mail and acknowledged touching the mailbox, according to the same account of what the order records. The judge found the renter’s account of the encounter consistent with his recorded complaints at the time and with his later reports. The order finds she prolonged the confrontation, declined to identify herself and questioned the man’s right to occupy the home.
The recording came from the investigator’s own smart glasses, the Citizen reported, and the order reads it against her claim of fear. The judge found the recording showed her holding the gun in her hand while facing the man as he walked away from her, and then raising the gun and pointing it at him. The order records her acknowledging that she threatened to kill the man while his back was turned to her. The judge found the man was angry, spoke loudly and used profanity, and found that he carried no weapon and made no threat of violence. The order also weighed the defendant’s age, prior surgeries and physical limitations in evaluating her claimed fear of an attack.
The defense argued that the weapon was merely displayed rather than used against the man, and the order rejects that argument. The judge found that pointing the gun at the man while threatening to shoot him constituted a threatened use of deadly force.
This paper could not read the court file itself, and the sourcing here is therefore the Citizen’s reporting, attributed throughout under the fair report posture. The circuit court’s public case search is gated behind a CAPTCHA that this newsroom cannot pass, which has been true since this paper first measured it in September. The ruling is not a finding of guilt, and it does not decide the aggravated assault charge the defendant now answers at trial. It allows the prosecution to proceed, and it leaves the defendant free to argue self-defense to a jury when the case is tried.
A criminal charge is an accusation, and this case is now at the middle of the court process rather than the end of it. The Tattler has entered the case in its disposition watch and will publish the outcome at the same prominence as this story.
Loading comments…