The St. Augustine City Commission adopted the Davis Shores parking program on Oct. 12, on a single motion and five votes to none, under an agenda heading that read No Public Hearing Required, and that heading is the part worth keeping in view as the rest of this unfolds. The program turns North and South Davis Shores over to resident hangtags for the length of the Nights of Lights season, and the ordinance beside it, 2026-23, raises the fine for parking in the expanded downtown zone to $100 from $35. The city attached to that ordinance a Business Impact Estimate, a document whose one job is to count the businesses a measure is likely to affect, and the city’s own answer in that box was None.

None is not a defensible answer on a commercial boulevard. Anastasia Boulevard at the foot of the Bridge of Lions is lined with the businesses the season is supposed to lift, and the program holds their customers’ and their workers’ curb space to residents during the exact evening hours those businesses live on. More than a dozen of them had asked the commission to reconsider before anyone filed anything. The brewery’s lawyer, Marcus Thompson of Trinity Law and Title, put it harder than this paper would, telling the St. Johns Citizen that the city cannot “claim on paper that zero local businesses will be hurt while cutting a backroom deal to lock out their customers and staff.” A reader can set the sharpest of that aside and still be left with the box. A city that writes None over the signatures of the people who drew the map has either not looked or would rather the number were not read aloud.

Hornski’s Brewing Co. and the company that owns its building at 100 Anastasia Boulevard went to circuit court on Nov. 10, the Citizen reported, asking a judge to stop the zones and the fine and to pull down the signs that carry the $100 figure. The part of their complaint that should trouble a reader with no stake in the brewery is the sequence. Their lawyer warned the city on Nov. 4 that a suit was coming. City Attorney Isabelle Lopez answered on Nov. 6 by pointing to a July 2024 zoning review that caps the brewery at 21 patrons on its seven parking spaces, and by noting that running past the cap without approved parking brings code enforcement. A Local Traffic Only sign went up beside the brewery’s driveway the day it filed. The timing is not subtle. The businesses read all of that as a threat, and a reader does not have to credit their every word to see why the order of events invites the reading.

The city’s position, in Lopez’s own words, is that the restrictions are a lawful exercise of its authority over its own streets, that no resident-only parking is proposed on Anastasia Boulevard itself, and that the fine and the zones are separable, so that stopping the $100 would leave the old $35 standing. The first point is most likely true and beside the point. A city may regulate its curbs; the question a hearing exists to answer is not whether it may but whether it should, and on whom, and at what cost to the boulevard the same city spends the season promoting. The second point is narrower than it sounds, because a visitor turned off a Davis Shores side street at 1 p.m. does not reach the boulevard’s front door by some other road.

Whether the $100 is even in force right now is itself contested. Thompson says state law freezes the increase the moment a qualifying challenge is filed, and Lopez’s letter reads the other way. A judge will take that up Thursday, Nov. 19, two days before the lights come on. That is the entire calendar left. This paper does not pretend to know how the stay question resolves, and it is not the point of this page to guess. The point is that the season the city is guarding its residents’ driveways for is the same season a business on the boulevard says it cannot plan around a fine that may or may not be suspended, and that uncertainty is the city’s to have prevented.

Consider what the city offered the boulevard, and when. For the five weeks between the Oct. 12 vote and the suit, the merchants got the program and the signs. Three days after Hornski’s filed, the city announced 60 free parking spaces for boulevard workers at the old Blue Water Jewelers lot at 500 Anastasia, the first accommodation it had made since the program passed, and its own release does not even give the number of spaces the Citizen had to count. An accommodation that arrives 72 hours after a lawsuit, and five weeks after the vote, is not a plan for the boulevard. It is a response to being sued, and the city is entitled to make it, but no one should mistake its timing for foresight.

This paper’s position is straightforward.

The commission adopted a program that takes a commercial boulevard’s parking during its best weeks, certified that it would hurt no one, and declined to hold the hearing that might have made it say otherwise. A business took the question to the one forum the city left open. The court should freeze the $100 fine while it hears the case, and the city should spend the days before Thursday deciding whether a program it passed under the words No Public Hearing Required can survive the hearing it is now going to get. The lights come on Saturday either way. The open question is who had to go to court to be heard first.

This is a column, the writer's argument, based on the facts shown above. Our news coverage is held to a separate standard, described on our standards page.