The Davis Shores parking program is in court. The lights come on Saturday.

Hornski’s Brewing Co. and the company that owns its building at 100 Anastasia Boulevard filed suit against the city on Tuesday, Nov. 10, the St. Johns Citizen reported this weekend, asking a judge to stop the resident-only parking zones and the $100 fine before Nights of Lights opens.

The program is the one the City Commission approved Oct. 12 on one motion, five to nothing, under an agenda heading that read No Public Hearing Required. North Davis Shores goes to resident hangtags from 1 to 9 p.m. every day of the season. South Davis Shores goes to them 1 to 9 p.m. Friday through Sunday. The fine in the expanded downtown zone is $100 under Ordinance 2026-23, four times the $35 it replaced, and the city opened hangtag applications Nov. 13.

The suit says the city skipped its own rules to get there. The retaliation claim is the part that goes further.

The letter and the zoning file

According to the Citizen’s account of the complaint, the businesses’ attorney wrote the city on Nov. 4 warning that a suit was coming. City Attorney Isabelle Lopez answered on Nov. 6. Her reply cited a July 2024 zoning review that limits the brewery to 21 patrons on the strength of its seven on-site parking spaces, and it noted that running past the limit without approved parking brings code enforcement. Hornski’s and Anastasia Boulevard Building LLC characterize that as a threat of retaliatory enforcement for going to court, and that characterization is now in the complaint.

The brewery also told the court a Local Traffic Only sign went up beside its driveway the day it filed, the Citizen reported. A city map dated Sept. 23 had proposed signs like it near the property, and the filing does not say whether Tuesday’s sign was one of those.

Lopez’s letter gave no ground. She wrote that the restrictions are a lawful exercise of the city’s authority over its own streets, and that “there is no proposed resident-only parking on Anastasia Boulevard/SR A1A, nor on other segments of local roads that are commercial.” The letter also keeps the two measures apart. If a court stops the $100 fine, the city’s position is that the zones hold at the old $35.

What the complaint says the record shows

The complaint attaches city records, as the Citizen describes them. Staff exchanged a photograph of a RESIDENT PARKING BY PERMIT ONLY sign carrying the $100 figure on Sept. 9. Senior staff met with the president of a Davis Shores neighborhood association about the program on Sept. 11. The Sept. 23 map drew the restrictions and marked seven locations for Local Traffic Only signs.

The businesses cite those dates as evidence the program was built before the fine increase was first discussed in public, which they put at Sept. 28. They also point at the city’s business-impact estimate for the fine ordinance, which listed None as the number of businesses likely to be affected. More than a dozen businesses on and near the boulevard had already asked the commission to reconsider.

“The $100 fine is frozen now, and we look forward to presenting the facts to the court on Thursday,” the businesses’ attorney, Marcus Thompson of Trinity Law & Title, told the Citizen. Their argument is that state law suspends a fine increase once a challenge meets the statute’s requirements. Lopez’s letter reads the other way, and nothing public from the city concedes the point.

Thursday is Nov. 19. The season opens two days later.

The city’s answer so far

The city declined to comment to the Citizen, saying it does not comment on pending litigation.

What it published instead was parking. On Nov. 13 the city announced free workforce parking for the boulevard at the former Blue Water Jewelers property, 500 Anastasia Blvd., with passes going to employees of corridor businesses that qualify. The Citizen put the count at 60 spaces. The city’s own release gives no number.

That release is the first thing the city has offered the boulevard’s merchants since the program passed, and it arrived three days after the suit was filed, which is fine.

The Tattler will report what the court does with the fine and with the zones.

The commission adopted this program in October under a heading that said no hearing was required. There is a hearing now. The city did not schedule it.