The man leaving the city manager’s office at St. Augustine Beach put a warning in front of the commission before it picks his successor. The preliminary background checks on the six finalists, his memo says, are not thorough.
Max Royle’s memorandum is dated Oct. 29 and rode the packet for Monday night’s commission meeting, item 5. It asks the commission to decide between trusting a screening that cost about $500 and paying an experienced firm for a real investigation. Whatever the commission chose, no posted record says yet. The city’s meeting highlights usually land within two days, and as of early Wednesday the newest one still covers Oct. 5.
Here is the search so far, as the memo tells it. Fifty-five people applied. Two senior advisors from the Florida City/County Management Association, Jim Hanson and Steve Kennedy, divided that list into eight recommended candidates and nine qualified but not recommended. At the Oct. 5 meeting, Commissioner Undine George added a candidate, and the commission settled on seven finalists: Dan Carswell, Peggy Castano, Shane Corbin, Thomas Enharth, Todd Grant, Madeline Hanlon and Timothy Owens. Carswell withdrew his name the next day.
That left six.
The city clerk then ordered what the memo calls the standard screening package from Justifacts, a screening company. The package covered records searches at the county, state and federal level, registry checks, a credit history, and verification of Social Security number and address history. Each finalist signed an authorization. The total cost was about $500.
Then comes the part of the memo a reader should sit with.
Under the heading ANSWERS, it says the preliminary checks are not thorough, and lists what they fail to do. They do not verify a degree or a transcript. They do not establish the real reasons a candidate left previous jobs, which the memo notes do not show up in public records when a manager resigns quietly for “personal reasons.” They do not explain employment gaps. They do not explain frequent job changes. They say nothing about what kind of leader or decision maker a candidate is, whether one has created a toxic work environment, how one handles a budget, or whether one actually carries out what an elected board directs.
The memo’s recommendation is to hire a firm to do all of that. The clerk prepared a request for proposals in September, with responses due Oct. 5. Two companies answered. The commission heard those results at the Oct. 5 meeting and chose to run the cheap screening first anyway. Monday’s question was whether that answer is now good enough.
The stakes are plain.
A city manager runs the day-to-day government of the beach city, and the person hired will outlast the commission that hires them. Royle’s memo puts the trade in one place: the commission set standards for this hire, and the document in front of it says the $500 version cannot tell them whether any finalist meets those standards.
This paper will report what the commission decided as soon as the city publishes it, in the highlights release or the minutes, whichever lands first. The record of the search to date says one thing clearly. The city knows exactly what it has not checked, because its own manager wrote it down, lettered a through h.
Loading comments…