The new county commission replaced a planning board member on Tuesday, two weeks after the old commission appointed her, the St. Johns Citizen reported. The vote was 3-2. Martin Pyszczymuka cast it. He had been sworn in hours earlier.

Krista Dubé takes the seat she was denied two weeks ago. Beth Tate loses it. Tate was appointed Nov. 3 and introduced herself at the agency’s Nov. 5 meeting, per the Citizen’s account.

That was the whole term.

The Planning and Zoning Agency hears rezonings and land use applications before the commission votes on them, which makes its seats the first look growth gets in this county, and makes an appointment worth fighting over twice in one month. The commission fills the seats, and it keeps them filled exactly as long as it pleases.

On Nov. 3, with Arnold still seated, the old commission split over this seat. Joseph and Taylor backed Dubé.

Clay Murphy, Christian Whitehurst and Sarah Arnold voted her down, 3-2, in the final month of Arnold’s term. Whitehurst then nominated Tate, who carried 4-1 with Taylor dissenting, the Citizen reported.

Two weeks later Arnold’s seat belonged to Pyszczymuka.

Near the end of Tuesday’s meeting, Joseph moved to replace Tate with Dubé, Taylor seconded, and the third vote was already seated, per the Citizen.

Whitehurst asked whether commissioners could “arbitrarily remove” an appointee, according to the report. A representative of the county attorney’s office answered that advisory board members serve “at the pleasure of the board.” A seat carries a four-year term, and the term lasts as long as three votes say it does.

The agency itself had recommended Dubé for this seat. Outgoing member Greg Matovina reviewed 19 applications and nominated her, and the agency backed her 6-1, the Citizen reported. Taylor called the Nov. 3 vote against that recommendation “very disrespectful” to the members who did the reviewing, per the same report.

Murphy took the other side Tuesday. He said Dubé’s Nov. 3 presentation left him with doubts, and he described Tate as active, nonpartisan and knowledgeable about county issues, according to the Citizen.

The Citizen reports Dubé serves on the Fruit Cove Estates homeowners association board, opposed a gas station and car wash project beside that neighborhood, and told the agency the fight sent her into the comp plan and the staff reports. It reports Tate chairs the chamber of commerce’s public policy committee and sits as treasurer on the Habitat for Humanity of St. Johns board.

Tate gave up her seat on the county’s conservation board to take the planning one, per the Citizen. Whitehurst asked Joseph to amend her motion to hand that seat back before it passed. Joseph said county legal staff had told her Tate would have to reapply for it. The motion passed without the change.

None of this sits in a posted record yet, and none of it will for a while, because the Clerk posts minutes only after the board approves them. The Clerk’s index rows for Nov. 17 carry agenda links only, which is fine. The draft minutes ride the Dec. 1 consent packet, and the roll will first exist on paper there.

This paper will read it.