The state licensed 69 Lewis Boulevard on Sept. 3, under number 6501525. I have been watching this room the way you watch a pot ever since: the week it was licensed and not open, the week the menu was live and eleven dishes were out of stock, the week the doors opened, the ribeye went up two dollars and the Blackboard Specials heading that had nothing under it in October grew twenty-three dishes with prices on them.
Six weeks in, the pot is boiling.
The room is at 4.5 across 33 reviews, up from 4.4 across 21 when I last looked on Oct. 22, and the five newest reviews Google served this week are five stars, every one of them. So the verdict is forming. Here is the interesting part. It is not about the food.
Read the tallies the review panel keeps. The things people mention twice or more: the renovation, live music, prime rib, oysters, calamari, a seafood potato, drinks, and, unusually, management. Not one dish gets named more than twice. The room gets named constantly. “We love an old Florida feel with upscale food and this place totally delivered! Marina views and great quality food,” one reviewer wrote a month ago. “Amazing renovation job,” wrote another. A third: “I used to eat at this place all the time but now its open under a new name. Came to check out the new restaurant and found it freshened up considerably. Inside is nice and bright!”
That is a crowd rating a waterfront, a remodel and an afternoon, with the plates riding along. For a seafood house that sells the water as hard as this one does, that is the business plan working exactly as written.
What the plates are doing in the meantime
The dishes that do surface are the right ones. “The pecan crusted grouper and prime rib sandwich were amazing,” wrote the reviewer who also reported that management brought drinks before the server could get there, on a Sunday patio with live country music going. The grouper is 24.95 on the menu this paper archived in October, the prime rib sandwich is 18.95, the calamari that one tally names is 13.95, and the Gulf oysters another names run 9 dollars the half dozen and 18 the dozen, which is still the math that tells you they expect you to order the dozen. A $19 sandwich drawing praise by name is earning its keep. Another reviewer took the blackened redfish, 19.95, at lunch on the deck, and called the prices reasonable, which on the water they are: the ceiling is the 36.95 ribeye, and most of the middle sits in the teens.
Nobody in the five served reviews mentions the datil chowder. It spent October out of stock, so I have questions, and the menu I am quoting is three weeks old. Prices and stock move. The figures here are what the room published Oct. 22, and the copy says so.
And management showing up twice in a review tally is worth one more sentence, because reviews mention managers when managers are on the floor. Six weeks into a second room, with the first one sitting inland on Capulet Drive, somebody is clearly standing in this building making it run. That is the single best sign a new room can give. It does not photograph.
What I’d order: the pecan crusted grouper, on the patio, before the band packs up.
Loading comments…